USA Daily News
Top US news in one place!


Rethinking Gratuity: Advocating for the Permanent Abolition of Tipping in Restaurants


"Opinion: Navigating the Tipping Debate — Will Chicago Truly Bid Farewell to Gratuity?

In the aftermath of Chicago's recent city council decision to phase out the "subminimum wage" for tipped workers over the next five years, the question of tipping's future in the city looms large. Corey Mintz, food reporter and author of 'The Next Supper,' shares insights into the complexities of this move and challenges the notion that it signals the end of tipping.

Chicago's lower minimum wage for tipped workers, currently at $9.48 per hour compared to $15.80 for other workers, has long been a point of contention. The recent decision, portrayed by some as the elimination of the "tips-as-wage system," has sparked diverse opinions. Economist Steve Hanke sees it as a lamentable day for diners, emphasizing the financial incentive of tips as crucial for managing and motivating service staff.

Conversely, Nick Kokonas, co-founder of restaurant software company Tock, anticipates a positive shift. He envisions a future where tips are entirely replaced by service charges, citing potential benefits such as equalized pay between cooks and servers, reduced discrimination, and seasonal stability of wages.

However, Mintz remains skeptical, drawing on his experience in Toronto, Ontario, where tipping still prevails in most restaurants. He suggests that, despite a few establishments transitioning to service fees, the majority will likely retain tipping. The fear of customer backlash due to increased menu prices and concerns about losing top servers to venues where earning potential is higher may outweigh the perceived advantages of abolishing tipping.

As the debate unfolds, Mintz encourages a nuanced understanding of the dynamics at play, challenging optimistic predictions and highlighting the intricacies that may shape the future of tipping in Chicago's dining scene."

"Rethinking Tipping: Breaking the Chains of an Outdated System

The recent legal changes in Chicago aiming to phase out the subminimum wage for tipped workers raise questions about the enduring nature of the tipping culture. While tipping is often presented as a voluntary gesture for exceptional service, Corey Mintz challenges this perception, arguing that it perpetuates a deceptive practice within the restaurant industry.

Tipping, he contends, has long served as a tool for restaurants to suppress labor costs, presenting the illusion of affordability while passing the responsibility of staff compensation onto customers. Despite the claim that tips supplement a livable wage, Mintz asserts that it merely replaces the need for fair compensation from employers.

Delving into the historical roots of tipping, Mintz reveals its troubling origins as a means to employ formerly enslaved Black workers without providing proper wages. This system, he argues, perpetuates economic racial discrimination and contributes to the suppression of wages for kitchen staff.

Advocating for a radical shift in the industry, Mintz proposes that restaurants abandon the tipping model altogether. Instead, he suggests paying a living wage to all staff, reflecting the true cost of labor in menu prices. This, he believes, would foster a more equitable relationship between diners and restaurant staff, eliminating the need for customers to act as involuntary benefactors.

Drawing on his experiences at a hospitality conference, Mintz highlights the common challenge faced by owners and managers in attracting and retaining quality staff. He explores innovative models within the industry, noting that non-tipping restaurants often provide better wages, benefits, and a more supportive work environment. In doing so, these establishments defy industry norms, promoting collaboration between cooks and servers rather than perpetuating pay disparities.

As the debate over the future of tipping unfolds, Mintz advocates for a fundamental reevaluation of the relationship between diners, staff, and the true cost of a dining experience."

"Empowering Change: Restaurants Redefining Success by Prioritizing Staff Satisfaction

Amidst the challenges of a labor shortage, some forward-thinking businesses have successfully revolutionized their approach to employee retention. The key lies in recognizing staff as service professionals with aspirations for career growth and a desire for respectful treatment. Unlike the outdated notion that cooks are driven by passion while servers are purely motivated by money, these establishments understand the importance of fostering an environment where all employees feel valued.

However, despite the current labor shortage crisis, a significant number of restaurants hesitate to reassess their employment models. In candid conversations with industry operators, a recurring obstacle emerges—the lack of diner understanding regarding how tips function. The persistence of misconceptions, such as the belief that "tips" stands for "to insure prompt service," reveals a disconnect that hampers the evolution of restaurant practices.

Another challenge lies in a minority of diners who wield tipping as a form of control over service staff, diminishing their value and expecting unwarranted familiarity. While this segment is in the minority, it poses a hindrance to the evolution of restaurant culture. For these establishments, breaking free from this cycle becomes crucial, as they risk being more captive to an abusive relationship than dedicated to providing memorable culinary experiences.

The text concludes with a hopeful plea for Chicago's hospitality leaders—and those across the nation—to seize this moment as a true turning point. It's an opportunity to redefine the dynamics of the restaurant industry, placing emphasis on the well-being and professional growth of their staff, and challenging outdated practices that hinder progress."

"In conclusion, the challenges and opportunities facing the hospitality industry in the wake of Chicago's recent decisions to phase out the subminimum wage for tipped workers underscore the need for a profound shift in restaurant practices. While some establishments have successfully embraced innovative models, prioritizing staff satisfaction and career growth, many remain reluctant to reassess their traditional employment structures.

The persistence of misconceptions among diners, coupled with the minority who misuse tipping as a form of control, presents a unique set of obstacles. Breaking free from these dynamics is essential for restaurants to truly evolve and provide memorable culinary experiences. The hope is that Chicago's hospitality leaders, and those in cities nationwide, will seize this moment as a genuine turning point.

It's an opportunity to challenge outdated norms, foster an environment of respect and collaboration, and redefine success beyond mere profit. By prioritizing the well-being of their staff and dismantling practices rooted in historical inequalities, restaurants can emerge as beacons of positive change in the industry. The time has come for a reimagining of the restaurant experience—one that acknowledges the value of every team member, fosters professional growth, and ultimately creates a more equitable and sustainable future for the entire hospitality community."