USA Daily News
Top US news in one place!


Resurrecting the Slayer: A Perspective on the Revival of 'Buffy the Vampire Slayer'


"Taking Back the Narrative: 'Slayers' Podcast and the Redemption of the Buffyverse"

Editor’s Sara Stewart is a film and culture writer who lives in western Pennsylvania. The views expressed here are her own. View more opinion on CNN.

For devoted "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" enthusiasts, the revelation of a podcast named "Slayers" may evoke a kaleidoscope of emotions. Set a decade after the culmination of the original "Buffy" storyline in 2013, this podcast picks up where the series left off, promising a fresh exploration of the Buffyverse. However, this announcement resonates against a backdrop of complex sentiments within the fanbase, marred by a tumultuous history since the show's conclusion two decades ago.

The turbulence surrounding "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" largely stems from serious allegations of verbal abuse and cruelty against the series creator, Joss Whedon. These accusations, which began surfacing in 2017 during the mainstream emergence of the #MeToo movement, cast a shadow over the beloved series. In a 2022 interview with New York magazine, Whedon addressed some of the claims without offering a definitive confession or apology. Describing certain conduct as "not mannerly," he reflected on his role as a showrunner and conceded to areas where improvement was necessary, stopping short of a full acknowledgment of wrongdoing.

Fans, grappling with their disappointment and anguish, have faced the challenge of separating the art from the creator. As highlighted by Caroline Framke in Variety, "Buffy" has evolved beyond the influence of its creator, becoming a collective effort shaped by numerous writers, actors, crew members, and fans over the decades.

Now, in a bold move to reclaim the narrative, key actors from Whedon's "Buffy" era are stepping into the limelight with a podcast titled "Slayers: A Buffyverse Story." Spearheaded by Amber Benson, who portrayed the witch Tara Maclay, and Christopher Golden, an accomplished author within the "Buffy" universe, the podcast presents an alternative path forward when a creator grapples with the weight of their own toxicity. The nine-episode series, recently released on Audible, emerges as a creative endeavor that could serve as a model for the industry, showcasing the resilience and adaptability of a cherished fictional world despite the challenges posed by its real-world creator.

"The Resonance of 'Slayers': Navigating the Uncharted Territory of a Buffyverse Podcast"

The podcast landscape is now echoing with the familiar voices of fan-favorite actors from the iconic "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" series, courtesy of the audacious venture titled "Slayers: A Buffyverse Story." A reunion of sorts, this auditory experience features beloved actors like Charisma Carpenter, James Marsters, Amber Benson, Anthony Head, Juliet Landau, Emma Caulfield Ford, Danny Strong, and James Charles Leary, the latter known to fans as the floppy-eared, amiable demon Clem. Notably absent are some stalwarts of the original series, including Sarah Michelle Gellar (Buffy), Alyson Hannigan (Willow), and David Boreanaz (Angel).

The podcast, creating a peculiar sensation of reuniting with old, fictional friends through the somewhat ancient medium of radio plays, promises an immersive experience. James Marsters' noir narration, steeped in a whiskey-soaked, borderline-campy British accent, is poised to evoke a shiver of delight among ardent "Buffy" enthusiasts.

As a conflicted longtime fan of "Buffy," the prospect of this podcast revival is met with a resounding "Bring it on!" The essence of auteur theory, often perturbing to film purists, is challenged here. Traditionally, a singular vision from a creator, writer, and director defines the character of films and series. Joss Whedon's indomitable influence, evident in "Buffy," "Angel," "Firefly," and "Dr. Horrible’s Singalong Blog," carved out the unmistakable Whedonesque niche. The very term became synonymous with the major blog dedicated to all things Joss.

Yet, "Slayers" doesn't precisely mirror the Whedonesque paradigm. While it manifests a clear affection and profound understanding of characters from "Buffy," with Whedon's approval but not his direct involvement, there's a distinct element of kindness woven into the series. This departure is noteworthy, especially considering Amber Benson's multifaceted role as a writer, director, producer, and actor. The podcast's narrative spotlight on Charisma Carpenter's Cordelia takes on added significance, given that Carpenter initiated a significant backlash against Whedon in 2021. Her allegations of a "hostile and toxic" work environment and cruel treatment ignited discussions about the darker aspects of the show's production.

"Slayers" emerges as a captivating exploration of uncharted Buffyverse territory, where the echoes of the past intertwine with a novel narrative approach. As listeners embark on this audio journey, the podcast not only revives fictional tales but also serves as a reflection of the evolving dynamics within the broader cultural and creative landscape.

"In the Wake of Turbulence: 'Slayers' Charts a New Course for the Buffyverse"

Amidst the storm of allegations and revelations about the toxic environment on the set of "Buffy the Vampire Slayer," the emergence of the "Slayers: A Buffyverse Story" podcast signifies a transformative chapter in the Buffyverse narrative. The backdrop is marred by serious accusations against series creator Joss Whedon, with Charisma Carpenter, who portrayed Cordelia Chase, among those vocalizing her experience. Carpenter detailed instances of manipulation, revealing that Whedon had asked her if she planned to keep her pregnancy and had allegedly weaponized her womanhood and faith against her.

The Hollywood Reporter documented these claims, shedding light on a distressing chapter in the show's history. Notably, Amber Benson, who played Tara Maclay, characterized the "Buffy" set as a "toxic environment," and now, she spearheads the "Slayers" podcast—a Whedon-free endeavor that represents a symbolic reclamation of the narrative.

For Carpenter, the podcast offers a cathartic opportunity to move forward with her character in a new and supportive environment. In her words to Variety, Carpenter emphasizes the communal effort behind creating "Buffy," involving hundreds of people rather than revolving around one individual. "Slayers" becomes a platform to empower Cordelia, allowing her to live out a resilient and empowering life while sharing wisdom gained from her battles. The endeavor is perceived as a poetic continuation, providing fans with permission to enjoy the show beyond the shadow of its troubled creator.

However, not every "Buffy" fan is ready to embrace this new iteration. Dan Kois, writing in Slate, reflects on the complex relationship fans once had with Whedon's distinct style—his crackling dialogue, laser-cut plots, and ruthlessness in challenging characters. Kois raises the question of whether being a true auteur demands a certain level of ruthlessness, suggesting a potential trade-off between creative brilliance and managerial shortcomings.

Yet, as we navigate this post-auteur era, some argue that the concept of fidelity to an original source should evolve. Gary R. Bortolotti and Linda Hutcheon, in the New Literary History journal, draw parallels between stories and genes, emphasizing their ability to replicate and adapt in changing environments. In a pop-cultural landscape where adaptations can breathe new life into familiar narratives, the key lies in creators willingly endorsing these transformations.

"Slayers" emerges not only as a podcast but as a symbol of resilience and adaptation within the Buffyverse. It prompts contemplation about the evolution of storytelling, the power of communal creation, and the potential for characters and franchises to thrive in new, carefully crafted iterations that honor the past while paving the way for a more inclusive and supportive future.

"In the Wake of Change: 'Slayers' and the Post-Auteur Era"

While Joss Whedon's endorsement of "Slayers: A Buffyverse Story" might not come as a surprise, it raises intriguing questions about the evolving landscape of series continuations and the role of original creators in endorsing new narratives. Drawing a parallel with J.K. Rowling's hypothetical stance on others running with Hogwarts characters or contemplating a continuation of "Mad Men" without its original showrunner, the text delves into the complex dynamics of series moving forward when key figures face controversy or are ousted.

The comparison extends to instances like the new season of "Rick and Morty," where the firing of Justin Roiland prompted changes in leading voices. The text also reflects on "House of Cards," which navigated the aftermath of sexual assault allegations against Kevin Spacey by killing off his character and continuing with Robin Wright in a central role.

However, "Slayers" stands out as a unique case, offering a seamless transition from its source material. The series finale of "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" provides a brilliant jumping-off point, as a spell disperses slayer abilities to girls worldwide, eliminating the concept of a singular empowered figure. This plot device becomes a metaphorical passing of the torch, allowing new creators to shape the narrative.

Amber Benson, a key figure in "Slayers," appears to embrace the post-auteur era, signaling a shift in the industry's dynamics. The text highlights a poignant piece of dialogue from "Slayers," spoken by the character Anya, emphasizing the potential for magic—whether real or metaphorical—to unite women in standing together. This sentiment encapsulates the essence of the series as it forges ahead into uncharted territory, shedding light on the power dynamics and opportunities for narrative evolution in the post-auteur landscape.

"In conclusion, 'Slayers: A Buffyverse Story' emerges not only as a podcast revival but as a symbol of the changing tides in the realm of series continuations. The endorsement from Joss Whedon, in the context of his troubled history with allegations, sparks contemplation on the role of original creators in the evolving landscape of storytelling. The comparisons drawn with other series facing controversies or key figure departures highlight the nuanced challenges and opportunities in crafting narratives beyond the auteur.

'Slayers' distinguishes itself by leveraging the ingenious plot device embedded in the final episode of 'Buffy the Vampire Slayer,' providing a metaphorical passing of the torch to new creators. Amber Benson's role in the podcast signifies a willingness to embrace the post-auteur era, reflecting a broader shift in the industry's dynamics.

The poignant dialogue from 'Slayers,' emphasizing the unity of women with magic—whether literal or metaphorical—captures the spirit of the series as it navigates uncharted territory. As the post-auteur era continues to unfold, 'Slayers' stands as a compelling example of how narratives can evolve, honoring the source material while paving the way for new voices and perspectives.

The Buffyverse, once defined by a singular vision, now embarks on a journey shaped by collaborative storytelling and a reimagining of familiar characters. 'Slayers' not only resurrects beloved fictional worlds but also signals a broader exploration of possibilities in a landscape where storytelling transcends the confines of its originators, creating a space for diverse voices to contribute to the ever-evolving tapestry of narratives."