USA Daily News
Top US news in one place!


Electrifying Velocity: Unveiling the Surprising Supremacy of Electric Cars Over Planes


Silent Pioneers: Electric Showdown in the E-Flight Challenge 2023

In the skies above the island of Norderney, just off the northwest coast of Germany, a tiny dark speck against a darkening sky marked the culmination of the E-Flight Challenge 2023. The Elektra Trainer aircraft, a bright orange beacon of electric innovation, descended gracefully, its near-silent approach belying the cutting-edge technology at play. The challenge had set the battery-powered aircraft against a formidable opponent—a Lucid Motors Air sports car, also electric—in a race from Gelnhausen, a grass airfield near Frankfurt-am-Main, to be the first to touch down on Norderney.

Spotting the Elektra Trainer from a distance proved no easy feat, given its diminutive size and muted approach, powered by electric engines that offered no audible clues about its position. The challenge, orchestrated by electric mobility enthusiasts, aimed to spotlight the advancing capabilities of electric technology in both air and land travel. The juxtaposition of an electric aircraft and an electric car in a competitive quest underscored the leaps taken by this promising and swiftly evolving technology.

Drawing inspiration from the early days of aviation, where competitive challenges defined pioneering feats, the E-Flight Challenge sought to carve its place in history. From Louis Blériot's English Channel hop in 1909 to Charles Lindbergh's iconic transatlantic solo crossing in 1927, aviation history has thrived on daring challenges. Now, a century later, that spirit of discovery has found a new frontier in electric aviation—a segment steadily expanding its horizons.

While electric cars have become mainstream globally, with countries like Norway seeing a majority of new vehicle sales being electric, the realm of electric aviation is still forging its path. The E-Flight Challenge stands as a testament to the relentless pursuit of progress in this niche industry, where innovation and competition converge to push the boundaries of what electric technology can achieve. As the world watches electric aviation take flight, the silent pioneers of the E-Flight Challenge have etched their mark in the ongoing narrative of technological evolution.

Powering the Skies: Navigating the Electric Flight Conundrum

In the quest for electric aviation, the E-Flight Challenge underscored a stark reality—the energy requirements for aircraft, even the smallest, surpass the capabilities of existing battery technology. The Elektra Trainer, a nimble two-seater used in the challenge, exemplifies the current limitations. Despite the strides made in electric cars, the energy density required for larger aircraft on extended flights remains elusive.

Existing batteries on the market fall short in power, hindering the prospects of electric aircraft on a broader scale. Attempting to augment battery size comes with a substantial weight penalty, compromising performance. Even ventures as ambitious as Heart Aerospace, known for its orders from industry giants like United Airlines, had to pivot to a hybrid-electric approach for its aircraft, recognizing the current constraints of pure electric propulsion.

Italian manufacturer Tecnam, in collaboration with Rolls-Royce and Widerøe, faced a similar reality, suspending its electric aircraft project after three years of research, citing the immaturity of battery technology. However, recent developments in the realm of battery technology offer a glimmer of hope. China's CATL, a global battery technology leader, announced a breakthrough with a 500 watt-hours-per-kilogram battery, nearly doubling the current market standard of around 270 watt-hours per kilogram. Additionally, Cuberg, the California-based subsidiary of Swedish battery giant Northvolt, revealed progress in lithium-metal batteries, boasting a 40% gain at 380 watt-hours per kilogram.

While these advancements are promising, electrifying larger airliners, such as the Airbus A320 and Boeing 737-sized aircraft dominating modern flights, remains a formidable challenge. Airbus and Boeing, behemoths in the aerospace industry, explore alternatives like hydrogen and sustainable aviation fuels for decarbonization, acknowledging the current impracticality of battery-powered large passenger aircraft. As the electric aviation journey unfolds, the intersection of innovation, battery technology, and industry giants' strategic choices will determine the trajectory of flight in a greener, more sustainable future.

Charting the Electric Skies: Navigating the Uncertain Flight Path

Amidst the uncertainties surrounding the future of electric aviation, experts advocate for a pragmatic "portfolio approach" to development. McKinsey's Robin Riedel emphasizes the need to narrow down uncertainties through continuous development, allowing for informed decisions on suitable solutions for distinct market segments. This cautious strategy acknowledges the dynamic landscape of electric aviation and the ongoing evolution of technologies.

A 2021 study by Riedel and his team at McKinsey spotlighted a crucial segment for potential decarbonization—flights under 600 miles, responsible for 17.4% of global commercial aviation emissions. Technologies like hybrid-electric, battery-electric, and hydrogen-fuel-cell electric planes present viable options for rapid decarbonization in this category. The environmental benefits aside, proponents of electric aviation highlight the economic advantages stemming from lower maintenance and operational costs, attributed to the simplicity of electric motors with fewer moving parts.

Berlin-based private aviation operator Air2E, a supporter of the E-Flight Challenge, eagerly anticipates the arrival of electric aircraft. CEO Norbert Werle draws a parallel with the early years of electric cars, citing Tesla's Roadster as a transformative catalyst. The prospect of cost reductions in electric aviation prompts the hope that these aircraft will not only contribute to environmental sustainability but also capture a share of traffic currently reliant on road transport.

Entrepreneurs like seize the opportunity, developing hybrid-electric short takeoff and landing (eSTOL) aircraft with the capacity for nine passengers or 2,500 lbs of cargo over distances up to 500 miles. The envisioned cost-effectiveness of these aircraft aims to make economically unviable routes viable, connecting underused airfields and fostering regional air mobility businesses.

As the electric aviation narrative unfolds, the industry remains at the intersection of environmental consciousness, technological advancement, and economic viability. The strategic interplay of these factors will shape the flight path towards a more sustainable and accessible future.

Navigating Hybrid Horizons: The Pragmatic Approach to Electric Flight

In the realm of electric flight, the Virginia-based firm participating in the E-Flight Challenge treads cautiously, opting for a hybrid-electric approach rather than an all-electric one. Similar to hybrid cars, this technology combines traditional fuel with an electric powertrain, offering a compromise between existing fuel-powered systems and the aspirational vision of fully electric flight. The firm, led by founder and CEO John Langford, emphasizes the viability of hybrid technology, asserting that it provides energy densities closer to those of turboprop aircraft already in operation by regional airlines.

Langford underscores the current impracticality of relying solely on battery-powered aircraft for specific missions, projecting that it may take decades for battery technology to achieve the necessary energy density. Drawing parallels with the automotive industry, he notes the 15-year transition from viable hybrid-electric to battery-only vehicles, predicting a potentially longer trajectory for the aviation sector. The hybrid-electric approach, in this context, emerges as a pragmatic step to immediately address emissions concerns, with room for improvement as battery technologies evolve.

The E-Flight Challenge serves as both an illustration of the challenges and a glimpse into the promise of electric flight. The race to Norderney showcased the Achilles heel of electric aircraft—their range. The Elektra Trainer, part of the aircraft team, had to make a pitstop for a two-and-a-half-hour recharge, ultimately losing the race to the Lucid Air car. The organizers, however, celebrated the achievement of proving the feasibility of fully electric cross-country flights in a single day. The progress made over the past three years, as highlighted by Morell Westermann, one of the challenge initiators, has been nothing short of astonishing, setting the stage for continued advancements in electric aviation.

Pioneering Electric Skies: From Records to Predictions

Morell Westermann, a dedicated advocate for electric aviation, has left an indelible mark on the industry. In 2020, he joined fellow enthusiasts in a record-setting flight from the Swiss Alps to Norderney, achieving six world records for electric-powered flights. The accolades included the longest distance flown electrically, the fastest average speed over 100 kilometers, the highest altitude, and the lowest number of stopovers.

The 700-kilometer journey, though groundbreaking, required three days and 11 recharging stops. Fast forward to the 2023 E-Flight Challenge, covering a 300-kilometer route between the Frankfurt area and the North Sea with just one stop. This stark reduction in stopovers showcases the relentless progress in electric aviation, with incremental advances enabling participants to cover greater distances, faster and, crucially, emissions-free.

Westermann, who indulges in flying electric planes during his free time, boldly predicts a compelling future for electric aviation. With confidence, he forecasts that by 2026—merely three years from now—technology will mature to the point where electric planes can cover significant distances in a single, uninterrupted journey. As electric aviation continues to soar to new heights, the horizon seems promising for a future where the skies are not just traversed but transformed.

Elevating the Electric Horizon: A Vision for Emission-Free Flight

The journey from the Swiss Alps to Norderney, marked by record-setting achievements in electric aviation, stands as a testament to the remarkable strides made in a short span. Morell Westermann, a stalwart in the realm of electric flight, has not only participated in groundbreaking flights but envisions a future where the technology matures to facilitate uninterrupted journeys.

The 2023 E-Flight Challenge serves as a checkpoint in this trajectory, highlighting the progress achieved in minimizing stopovers and maximizing efficiency. The relentless pursuit of advancements in electric aviation promises a future where distances are covered in a single, emissions-free journey. Westermann's bold prediction for 2026 reflects the collective optimism of electric aviation enthusiasts, anticipating a landscape where technology propels planes further and faster, reshaping the skies into a realm of sustainable possibilities. As the industry continues to soar, the promise of emission-free flight beckons on the horizon, embodying a vision that transcends records to redefine the very essence of air travel.