USA Daily News
Top US news in one place!


Voices Unveiled: Perspectives from Pro-Palestinian and Pro-Israeli Supporters


"Voices Echoing: Perspectives from Pro-Israel and Pro-Palestine Demonstrators"

Since October 7, impassioned crowds have convened globally, using rallies as a platform to express their deep-seated frustrations, outrage, and fears surrounding the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas. In a poignant moment on a brisk Tuesday in Washington, DC, pro-Israel demonstrators gathered on the National Mall, clad in the blue and white hues of the Israeli flag. Their call resonated for the release of hostages held by Hamas, a plea against rising antisemitism in the US, and an insistence on unwavering American policies towards Israel.

Rabbi Adam Roffman, attending with Rabbi Shira Wallach from Congregation Shearith Israel in Dallas, articulated the sentiment: "As Jews, we don't want to feel alone. Throughout our history, we've often felt isolated. The opportunity to stand here, not just with Jews but with supporters of Israel, after a difficult and emotionally gut-wrenching month, fills us with hope and joy."

Contrastingly, at a pro-Palestinian gathering in New York City's Columbus Circle just days earlier, demonstrators carried Palestinian flags and homemade signs advocating for an immediate ceasefire and condemning the harm to children. Accusations of Israeli apartheid and genocide were voiced, and a plea for American leaders to reassess their support for Israel echoed through the crowd.

Laila Rodenbeck, a 24-year-old attendee at the pro-Palestinian rally, reflected on her feelings: "I go through periods of extreme distress and anguish over what's happening. It's only when I attend one of these rallies that I come back feeling a little bit more hopeful that the tides are starting to change."

CNN engaged with participants from both rallies to delve into their motivations and aspirations. The following encapsulates their perspectives and reasons for participating in these gatherings.

"Masked Voices, Unveiled Convictions: Anonymity and Activism at Pro-Palestinian and Pro-Israel Rallies"

Privacy and safety concerns have shrouded the participants of Friday's pro-Palestinian rally in a cloak of anonymity. Many chose not to disclose their last names to CNN, donning medical masks or the distinctive black and white keffiyeh, a traditional scarf, concealing their faces. This precautionary measure reflects a growing apprehension about potential identification or doxxing—a form of online privacy invasion—stemming from their political views.

Elizabeth, a 42-year-old teacher pushing her 2-year-old daughter's stroller, joined the demonstrations driven by images of children suffering in Gaza. "It's because I have a daughter, and I see all those children (in Gaza). We just don't want to support people being bombed," she expressed.

Seventy-year-old nurse and adjunct lecturer Elizabeth Oram, waving a Palestinian flag during the march, conveyed her longstanding support for Palestinian rights. Witnessing the situation in the occupied territories evolve from "very bad to absolutely barbaric," she emphasized the need to speak out against what she perceives as a potential genocide. "I'm 70. I need to be able to tell my grandchildren that when this happened, when a genocide happened, that I did not sit still – that I spoke out. That's what I need them to know," she asserted.

Sami, a 20-year-old French student visiting New York, decided to attend the rally after encountering distressing images of the violence in Gaza on social media. Expressing deep empathy, he said, "I feel a lot of pain for them, and I want this massacre and this genocide to stop."

In contrast, Tuesday's "March for Israel" in DC drew thousands of supporters, marking what is believed to be the largest pro-Israel gathering in the U.S. since the conflict began. Demonstrators, openly expressing their solidarity, wielded Israeli flags, held signs demanding the release of hostages, and adorned clothing with the faces of those held captive. The diverse narratives at these rallies reflect a complex tapestry of emotions, activism, and the evolving dialogue surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict."

"Individual Stories, Collective Convictions: Diverse Perspectives at Pro-Israel Rally"

The rally on Washington, DC's National Mall brought together a tapestry of personal narratives and collective convictions. Sara Blau, a University of Maryland student, wore a T-shirt featuring the face of Omer Neutra, a high school friend believed to be held hostage by Hamas, expressing her pride as a Zionist and a Jew, emphasizing solidarity with her community.

Michal and Noam Sheps, a couple from New Jersey, attended to show support for hostages and Israel, emphasizing the unity of one nation supporting each other for peace and safety. Sharon Strauss, 64, from Maryland, donned an Israeli flag and LGBTQ+ Star of David, highlighting her concerns for the LGBTQ+ community's safety in regions dominated by groups like Hamas and ISIS.

For Pritam, a New York University student, the rally was an opportunity to support the Muslim community and speak up for those impacted. Lulu, a 24-year-old graduate student, attending with a mix of anger, rage, and resistance, expressed concerns about the safety of pro-Palestinian supporters being doxxed for their views. Gurmukh, a 23-year-old research assistant, emphasized standing for basic human rights, aiming to be on the right side of history amidst the complex backdrop of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict."

"Beyond Politics and Religion: A Plea for Humanity at Pro-Israel Rally"

Amidst the charged atmosphere of the pro-Israel rally on Washington, DC's National Mall, one voice echoed a sentiment transcending politics and religion. An unnamed participant emphasized the essential need to take care of people, emphasizing a humanitarian perspective in the face of ongoing hostilities.

However, personal safety concerns lingered among pro-Israel demonstrators, particularly Jewish Americans. Josh Segel, a student at Towson University, expressed newfound wariness about displaying his Jewish identity, fearing potential hostility. Noam Sheps echoed this unease, stating that as an American Jew, he had never felt so uneasy before.

Evan, a 24-year-old resident of a densely populated Jewish area, highlighted persistent fears even within such communities. Despite residing in a familiar setting, concerns about safety remained prevalent.

The sentiment extended to the broader purpose of the rally, with many attendees advocating for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza. Derek, a 35-year-old massage therapist, held a cardboard sign reading "Cease Fire Now!" He articulated the shared desire for a reality where Israelis and Palestinians could coexist harmoniously, rejecting the notion of one side prevailing over the other.

In this multifaceted narrative, the rally became a platform not only for political advocacy but also for individuals to voice their concerns, fears, and hopes for a peaceful resolution to the conflict."

The term "terrorist organization" is a subjective designation, and perspectives on specific groups may vary. Different parties may classify organizations differently based on their geopolitical stance, beliefs, and policies. It's essential to consider multiple perspectives and consult reputable sources for a comprehensive understanding of specific organizations and their designations.

"Correction Acknowledged: Clarification on Photo Caption in Previous Version"

In a commitment to accuracy, it is acknowledged that the previous version of this story featured an inaccurate caption on a photo, specifically regarding a necklace. The charm on the necklace was accurately described as depicting a map of Israel and the occupied Palestinian territories. The correction emphasizes the importance of precision in media reporting and aims to provide an accurate portrayal of the details in question.

The correction made in acknowledging the inaccurate caption on the photo emphasizes a commitment to journalistic accuracy and responsible reporting. It underscores the significance of providing precise information to ensure a clear and truthful representation of the subject matter. In journalistic integrity, corrections play a crucial role in maintaining the trust of the audience and upholding the standards of factual reporting.